There may come a time when the jewelry you have is no longer representative of the person you are today. Perhaps it’s time to celebrate the freedom of a big life change, or it may simply be time to make room for new treasures. KOTLER’S has a team of knowledgeable and experienced buyers; specializing in fine jewelry, diamonds, and watches. Whether you choose to visit our Long Island, New York location or send in your treasures through our FREE and insured FedEX overnight delivery service, there is NOT an easier, more reputable selling experience in the world. We guarantee it!

KOTLER’S jewelry buyers purchase all types of jewelry ranging from broken gold, miss-matched earrings to a 5ct Tiffany & Co. Platinum engagement ring – to an entire estate of Belle Époque Jewelry by the most prestigious makers of the period: Tiffany, Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, David Webb, Buccellati, Oscar Heyman, and others.

We guarantee each piece will be evaluated individually, noting its quality, maker, materials, value, and historical significance. You will receive a purchase offer and immediate payment via cash or certified funds.